Pet Holiday & Party
Dog Christmas Cookie Recipes to Bake
Baking dog cookies for Christmas is the kind of holiday project that sounds simple and goes wrong in the same three places every year. The peanut butter jar has a label that needs reading. The raw dough on the counter needs to stay out of reach. And the nut tin that sits open on the counter for the human cookies has one nut in it that never goes near a dog. This page walks all three, and the cutters and the plain dough that make the rest of the baking afternoon easy.
By PawStyle Daily · Updated 19 November 2026
Plain dough only · label check on the jar · raw dough off the counter · for informational purposes, consult your vet.

Baking for the dog on the holiday counter
The dog cookie is the simplest thing on the holiday baking list. The dough has four or five ingredients, the cutters are the fun part, and the oven does the rest. The tricky part is not the dough. The tricky part is the counter. The same counter that holds the dog cookies also holds the human cookies, and the human cookies have chocolate, macadamia nuts, and raw dough that needs to rise. A clean counter is the whole recipe, and the clean counter is the one that has the dog ingredients on one side and the human ingredients on the other, with nothing crossing the line.
The dog cookie dough is a plain dough. Peanut butter, pumpkin puree, plain flour, and maybe an egg. No sugar, no salt, no butter, and nothing from the human cookie jar. The Christmas dog treats with peanut butter and pumpkin page has the full dough, and this page is the companion piece: the label checks, the counter rules, and the cutters that make the afternoon work.
Why raw dough stays out of reach
Raw dough can swell in the stomach and bloat, and the yeast in it turns into alcohol as it sits there. That is the line that keeps raw dough off the dog counter and off the floor. The dog who finds a piece of raw dough on the counter is the dog who eats it, and the dough that swells in a warm stomach is the dough that turns a baking afternoon into a vet visit. The rule is simple: raw dough stays in the bowl, on the counter, in the oven, or in the bin. It never goes on the floor, and it never goes in the dog.
The dog cookie dough does not have yeast in it, which is one of the reasons it is the easier dough to bake on a holiday afternoon. The human bread dough and the human cookie dough are the ones that rise, and those are the ones that stay on the far side of the counter, covered, and away from the edge. A dog who can reach the counter is a dog who needs the dough in the oven before the oven is the next stop, and a dog who cannot reach the counter is a dog who still needs the floor swept before the cookies come out.
The peanut butter label check
Xylitol is a sweetener that can drop a dog's blood sugar and hurt the liver, so it never goes into a homemade treat. The peanut butter jar is the one place xylitol hides in a baking kitchen, and the label check is the one step that stands between the dough and the dog. Turn the jar around. Read the ingredient list. If the word xylitol appears, the jar stays on the human shelf and a different jar comes out for the dog cookies.
Only a few peanut butter brands add xylitol, so read the ingredient label on the jar before a spoonful goes in the bowl. Most jars on the shelf are plain peanuts and salt, and those are the ones that go in the dog dough. The peanut butter label check page has the full list of brands to look for, and the shortcut is the same every time: if the label says xylitol, the jar stays on the human side. For informational purposes, consult your vet.

The nut list off the counter
Chocolate is toxic to dogs, so no chocolate, cocoa or coffee ever goes into a treat. On the baking afternoon, that means the chocolate chips stay in the human cookie dough and never cross to the dog side of the counter. The cocoa powder stays in the tin. The coffee that some bakers add to chocolate cookies stays in the mug. The dog cookie dough has none of these, and the clean counter is the one where the chocolate is on one side and the dog dough is on the other.
Macadamia nuts can leave a dog weak, wobbly and running a fever, so they stay out of the treat jar. The open tin of mixed nuts on the counter is the one that catches people, because the macadamia looks like every other nut in the tin and a dog who walks past the counter will take one. The tin stays closed, stays on the back of the counter, and stays away from the edge. The no-bake peanut butter treats page skips the oven entirely, which is the other way to keep the counter clean on a busy baking day.
Cookie cutters and the plain dough
The cutters are the fun part of the afternoon, and the small bone and star shapes are the ones that bake evenly and fit in a treat jar. Roll the dough to an even thickness, cut the shapes close together to get the most out of the batch, and put the scraps back through the roller one more time. The cookies go in the oven on a plain baking sheet, no grease, no paper, and they come out firm and dry. Let them cool on the sheet before the first taste, because a hot cookie is a soft cookie and a soft cookie is a cookie that crumbles in the jar.
The cutters stay plain. No icing, no drizzle, no sprinkles. The dog cookie is the plain version of the holiday cookie, and the cutter shape is the only decoration it needs. A bone-shaped peanut butter cookie on a holiday plate is the version that looks like Christmas and acts like a treat. For informational purposes, consult your vet.

Questions about baking dog Christmas cookies
Can I use cookie cutters for dog treats?
Yes, and the small bone and star shapes are the ones that bake evenly. Keep the dough plain, skip the icing, and let them cool before the first taste.
Is peanut butter OK in dog cookies?
Most jars are fine, but a few brands add a sweetener that drops a dog's blood sugar. Read the ingredient label on the jar before the spoonful goes in.
What stays off the baking counter?
Chocolate, the raw dough that swells in the stomach, and the macadamia nuts that sit in the tin. A clean counter is the whole recipe.

The cookie cutter kit
What makes the dog cookie afternoon easy
A set of small bone and star cutters and a silicone baking mat - the two things that turn a plain peanut butter dough into a batch of holiday cookies that look like Christmas and act like a treat.
See the cutter kit →As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Save these on Pinterest
Pin the cookie counter rules before the baking afternoon starts. The Holiday collection holds the seasonal pages that keep the holiday kitchen clean, and the toxic-foods page that keeps the keep-out ingredients visible.